Price & Cost Benchmarking

Competitive Analysis Report

Industry benchmarks, cost position analysis, and optimization opportunities

Apex Manufacturing Corp.
Manufacturing, $500M-$1B
Sample Report
42
percentile

Below Median

Your overall procurement cost position places you in the 42nd percentile among manufacturing companies with $500M-$1B revenue. This indicates meaningful opportunities to improve cost competitiveness.

8.2% Gap to Median
14.6% Gap to Top Quartile
$168M
Total Spend Analyzed
12
Categories Benchmarked
$8.4M
Gap to Median
$14.2M
Gap to Top Quartile

Key Findings

Underperforming Categories

  • Indirect Materials - 15% above median
  • Logistics & Freight - 11% above median
  • Professional Services - 14% above median
  • MRO - 10% above median

Strong Performers

  • Raw Materials - At median
  • Packaging - 3% below median
  • Utilities - 5% below median
  • Capital Equipment - At top quartile

Summary

Achieving median performance across all categories would deliver $8.4M in annual savings. Reaching top quartile performance would unlock $14.2M. Four categories account for 72% of the total gap, making them priority targets for cost reduction initiatives.

Indirect Materials ($24.6M annual spend)
$2.1M opportunity
Your Cost: 12.4%
Median: 10.8%
Top Quartile: 9.2%
Your Position
Industry Median
Top Quartile
15%
Above Median
35th
Percentile
126
Suppliers
High
Priority
Logistics & Freight ($18.2M annual spend)
$1.34M opportunity
Your Cost: 8.2%
Median: 7.4%
Top Quartile: 6.5%
Your Position
Industry Median
Top Quartile
11%
Above Median
38th
Percentile
28
Suppliers
High
Priority
Professional Services ($12.8M annual spend)
$1.51M opportunity
Your Cost: 6.8%
Median: 5.9%
Top Quartile: 5.1%
Your Position
Industry Median
Top Quartile
14%
Above Median
36th
Percentile
89
Suppliers
High
Priority
Facilities & MRO ($8.4M annual spend)
$670K opportunity
Your Cost: 4.2%
Median: 3.8%
Top Quartile: 3.2%
Your Position
Industry Median
Top Quartile
10%
Above Median
40th
Percentile
156
Suppliers
Medium
Priority
Category Annual Spend Your Cost % Median % Top 25% % Gap to Median Opportunity
Indirect Materials $24.6M 12.4% 10.8% 9.2% +1.6% $2.10M
Professional Services $12.8M 6.8% 5.9% 5.1% +0.9% $1.51M
Logistics & Freight $18.2M 8.2% 7.4% 6.5% +0.8% $1.34M
IT Hardware & Software $12.4M 5.2% 4.8% 4.1% +0.4% $890K
Facilities & MRO $8.4M 4.2% 3.8% 3.2% +0.4% $670K
Marketing & Advertising $6.2M 3.6% 3.2% 2.8% +0.4% $520K
Fleet & Travel $4.8M 2.9% 2.6% 2.2% +0.3% $380K
Raw Materials $42.8M 21.6% 21.6% 19.8% 0% At Median
Packaging $18.4M 9.1% 9.4% 8.6% -0.3% Below Median
Utilities $8.6M 4.1% 4.3% 3.9% -0.2% Below Median
Capital Equipment $10.2M 5.0% 5.4% 4.9% -0.4% Top Quartile

Gap to Industry Median

$8.4M

5.0% of addressable spend

Gap to Top Quartile

$14.2M

8.5% of addressable spend

1
Indirect Materials Consolidation & Renegotiation
$1.8M - $2.1M
Consolidate 126 suppliers to preferred vendor network. Implement catalog buying with volume-tiered pricing. Negotiate annual rebates with top 10 suppliers representing 65% of spend.
Timeline
4-6 months
Complexity
Medium
Target Percentile
55th
2
Logistics Network Optimization
$1.1M - $1.4M
Conduct freight RFP with national and regional carriers. Implement TMS for rate optimization and load consolidation. Renegotiate parcel agreements leveraging competitive bids.
Timeline
3-5 months
Complexity
High
Target Percentile
60th
3
Professional Services Rate Card Implementation
$1.2M - $1.5M
Establish preferred supplier program with negotiated rate cards by role type. Implement SOW templates and approval workflows. Reduce reliance on premium consulting rates.
Timeline
3-4 months
Complexity
Medium
Target Percentile
50th
4
MRO Tail Spend Management
$500K - $700K
Deploy integrated supplier marketplace for MRO purchases. Implement P-card controls with preferred routing. Consolidate 156 suppliers to 25 strategic partners.
Timeline
2-3 months
Complexity
Low
Target Percentile
50th

Total Improvement Opportunity

$8.4M - $14.2M
Achievable within 12-18 months through systematic execution

Savings Capture by Phase

Quick Wins (0-3 months)
$2.8M
Strategic Sourcing (3-9 months)
$5.2M
Sustained Improvement (9-18 months)
$3.4M

Expected Percentile Progression

Milestone Percentile Position Cumulative Savings
Current State 42nd Below Median -
End of Phase 1 (3 months) 48th Approaching Median $2.8M
End of Phase 2 (9 months) 58th Above Median $8.0M
End of Phase 3 (18 months) 68th Third Quartile $11.4M

Benchmarking Methodology

This analysis compares your procurement costs against a curated peer set based on:

  • Industry: Manufacturing sector (SIC codes 20-39)
  • Revenue Band: $500M - $1B annual revenue
  • Geography: North America operations
  • Sample Size: 247 organizations in benchmark database
  • Data Currency: Updated quarterly, last refresh December 2024

Cost percentages are calculated as spend category / total company revenue to normalize for size differences. Opportunity values are estimated using your actual spend volumes applied to benchmark cost rates.